This article contains spoilers through Given: To the Sea (2024).
There is a difference between loving someone who has an ex, and loving someone who has lost someone.
It is not a small difference.
An ex is an ending. A relationship that finished — through distance, through incompatibility, through the slow erosion of something that once worked. Painful, sometimes. But finished.
Death is not an ending.
Death is a stopping. Right in the middle of something. Before the argument was resolved. Before the words got said. Before anyone chose for it to be over.
The love didn’t end. The person did.
And the one left behind is still holding something that has nowhere to go.
Given understood this completely.
And Ritsuka Uenoyama chose to love that person anyway.
“It Stopped in the Middle” — What Makes Grief After Death Different
When Yuki died, he and Mafuyu had been in the middle of a fight.
They hadn’t made up. The things that needed to be said hadn’t been said. The relationship hadn’t been given a chance to resolve itself — to soften, to heal, to find its way to something finished.
It simply stopped.
Which means that inside Mafuyu, the relationship with Yuki never ended. It froze. Mid-sentence. Mid-feeling. With no conclusion available, because the person who could have provided one was gone.
This is fundamentally different from the grief of a breakup.
After a breakup, however painful — however long it takes — there is a fact to eventually rest against: it ended. Time can move. Things can shift.
After death, there is no such fact. The feeling doesn’t end because the relationship ended. The feeling has nowhere to go because there is no ending. Only a stopping.
Mafuyu wasn’t holding onto the past because he couldn’t let go.
He was holding onto something that had never been given the chance to complete itself.
To Love Someone Who Carries This
When Ritsuka fell for Mafuyu, he was falling for the whole of him.
Not just the present version — the quiet boy with the extraordinary voice, the person slowly coming back to life through music.
But also the part of Mafuyu that belonged to Yuki. The part that was still frozen in the middle of something unfinished. The grief that had no clean edge. The guilt that couldn’t be resolved because the person who might have resolved it was no longer there.
Ritsuka couldn’t ask Mafuyu to forget Yuki.
Not because it would be unkind — though it would be — but because Yuki wasn’t separable from Mafuyu. The love Mafuyu had carried for Yuki, the loss he had lived inside for years, the person he had become in the aftermath of that loss — all of it was Mafuyu.
To ask him to set it down would be to ask him to set down part of himself.
So Ritsuka didn’t ask.
He received it instead.
For the full portrait of what Mafuyu was carrying — and where his silence came from: ✅ Mafuyu Sato from Given: What His Silence Is Actually Made Of
How Japanese Storytelling Handles Grief — Not Overcoming, But Carrying
There is a difference in how grief tends to be framed in Western versus Japanese storytelling — and Given sits very clearly in the Japanese tradition.
In much of Western fiction, recovery from loss follows a recognisable arc. You grieve. You struggle. Eventually, you move forward. You find new love, new purpose, a new version of yourself that has processed the pain and emerged on the other side. The goal, implicitly, is to get through it.
Japanese storytelling often imagines something different.
Not getting through grief. Living alongside it.
Not setting down what you’ve lost. Carrying it with you — into new relationships, into new mornings, into whatever comes next.
The person you lost doesn’t disappear from your story. They stay in it. They travel with you. They become part of how you love the next person.
Given is one of the most honest expressions of this I have encountered.
Mafuyu doesn’t move on from Yuki. He moves forward with Yuki still inside him. And Ritsuka doesn’t ask him to arrive without that weight.
He meets him there, in the middle of it, and stays.
What Ritsuka Actually Chose to Carry
In Given: To the Sea, Ritsuka is handed something almost impossible.
Yuki’s unfinished song. Written for Mafuyu. Never delivered.
Ritsuka’s first response was honest: he didn’t want to do it.
Of course he didn’t.
To complete that song meant holding in his own hands the evidence of how deeply Mafuyu had once been loved by someone else. To shape it. To send it toward the person he loved — on behalf of the person who came before him.
The jealousy was real. The pain was real. The resistance was entirely understandable.
But Ritsuka listened to the song.
And he heard it — the depth of what Yuki had wanted to say, the feeling that had been stopped mid-sentence, the love that had nowhere to go.
And something shifted.
Not the end of his own pain. But the arrival of a clarity that mattered more:
This has to reach him.
Because delivering Yuki’s love to Mafuyu was not a defeat. It was the most complete expression of his own love that Ritsuka could offer.
I see everything you’ve been carrying. I’m not asking you to put it down. I’m going to help you carry it.
That is what completing that song meant.
For the full story of what that choice cost — and what it revealed about Ritsuka: ✅ Ritsuka Uenoyama from Given: The Boy Who Acts Before He Thinks
For the moment that song finally arrived — and the four kinds of love that converged in it: ✅ When Your Partner Finishes Their Ex’s Love Song — What Given: To the Sea Understands About Love
What It Might Mean to Love Someone Who Has Lost Someone
If you love someone who is carrying a loss like Mafuyu’s, some things may be true.
Their grief will not fully disappear. Not with time. Not with love. Not with anything you can offer.
There will be moments — quiet ones, unexpected ones — when the person they lost moves through the room. When a song comes on, or a season changes, or something small triggers something large. And they will feel it again, fresh, in the middle of an ordinary day.
This is not a failure of their love for you.
It is what grief after death is.
And your own feelings in those moments are also real. The jealousy. The helplessness. The strange, disorienting experience of competing with someone who is no longer alive to compete with.
Ritsuka felt all of it.
The difference is what he chose to do with it.
He didn’t ask Mafuyu to resolve the grief before Ritsuka could fully arrive. He arrived anyway, into the middle of it, and stayed.
That is not something everyone can do.
It requires a particular kind of love — one that is less concerned with being the only thing, and more concerned with being present for the whole person. The past included.
What Given Leaves You With
Given never suggested that Mafuyu needed to be finished grieving before he deserved to be loved.
It never suggested that Ritsuka’s love was less real because it shared space with Yuki’s memory.
It held both things at once — the old love and the new, the grief and the beginning, the person who was gone and the person who stayed.
Loving someone who has lost someone doesn’t mean waiting for them to be over it.
It means deciding that the whole of them — including the part that still hurts, including the part that still belongs to someone else — is worth staying for.
Ritsuka stayed.
That, in the end, is what the whole story was about.
If this resonated with you, these go deeper:
✅ Mafuyu Sato from Given: What His Silence Is Actually Made Of
✅ Ritsuka Uenoyama from Given: The Boy Who Acts Before He Thinks
✅ Yuki from Given: The Character Who Isn’t There — and Never Really Leaves
✅ When Your Partner Finishes Their Ex’s Love Song — What Given: To the Sea Understands About Love
✅ What Is Given? — Where to start if you’re new to the series
I also share the small manga moments that stay with me long after reading—the pauses, glances, and choices that never fully leave.
You can follow those weekly reflections on Substack.
✅ My Substack Here!
